“Posterity! You will never know how much it cost the present Generation to preserve your Freedom! I hope you will make good use of it. If you do not, I shall repent in Heaven, that I ever took half the Pains to preserve it.”
Every Memorial Day I think of this quote by John Adams, in one of the many letters he sent to his wife Abigail while he was away from the family helping get a new country established (and she was running a farm and raising 5 children...gee I wonder who was working harder?!) “Posterity! You will never know how much it cost the present Generation to preserve your Freedom! I hope you will make good use of it. If you do not, I shall repent in Heaven, that I ever took half the Pains to preserve it.” Add Comment This Sunday at 2pm is Newton's Memorial Day parade. The route goes from Our Lady's church on Washington Street in Newton Corner, down to Walnut Street in Newtonville, and ends at Chapel Street in Nonantum. This year there is a FREE BARBECUE at the end of the parade route, at Pellegrini Park. Attending the parade is a simple way to recognize the holiday which honors those who gave their lives so that we might have the freedoms and quality of life that we Americans are privileged to enjoy. Hope to see you there! Last night's meeting was quite interesting. Social & Emotional Learning First there was a power point presentation on "social and emotional learning", mostly in elementary school. Many parents know about the "open circle" and anti-bullying efforts. Instructional Rounds According to David Fleishman, "Instructional Rounds” began 5 years ago and was designed by Harvard Ed School professor Richard Elmore, modeled after medical rounds in which groups of teachers and administrators from across the city do focused and intense visits at each school to observe, learn, and share ideas. It is not intended to be punitive in any way; David Fleishman said "It’s describe and define, not evaluate." He said, "It’s amazing what you can see in one hour." (Here is the power point presentation that was shown) - Reinforces goals of school improvement plan. - Principals come back and share with their own school what they have observed. The Mason-Rice principal said these rounds "made us feel like we’re part of something bigger," made staff feel important to have people from across the city coming into their classrooms. Teaching can be an isolating profession - another teacher said going on the rounds and having others observe her made her feel more professional, especially at a time when the teaching profession is under a lot of criticism. It seems like these instructional rounds are a terrific advance and kudos to the superintendent for initiating it. I'm a bit late posting my update to the April 9 SC meeting, but April "vacation" with the kids home didn't leave much time for blogging. There were 2 big items from this meeting: Summer starts a week early June 15 is the last day of school, thanks to the dearth of snow days this year. (And June 15 is a half day). I'm guessing a lot of parents will be looking for somewhere to park their kids that week! Elementary School Buildings Deputy Superintendent Sandy Guryan presented this power point which is definitely worth your while to look at and which clearly took a lot of creativity and hard thinking about addressing our myriad of issues. She offers two “scenarios” in which the condition and space constraints of our elementary schools would finally be solved. She emphasizes that these are not plans set in stone, but rather concrete ideas that can be adjusted. It is quite an improvement over the previous Long Range Facilities Plan which would have taken three decades to carry out. She starts out talking about the “challenges” – aging buildings, growing population, residential development, funding constraints, etc. – and then the “Desired Outcomes”: - Up-to to-date teaching and learning facilities - Capacity for 6,000+ elementary students - Maximize state funding - Explore/create model schools* - Phased and continuous use of swing space - Maintain neighborhood schools - Balance North/South feeder pattern - Eliminate/reduce modular classrooms - Consolidate preschool location Basically her idea is to create additional capacity and improve facilities via a mixture of large scale renovations that would increase capacity at each school (up to cap of 450 students) and be completed in 2 or 4 year cycles, simultaneously with smaller renovation projects that would increase capacity and add improvements where necessary such as cafeterias, dedicated art and music rooms, smaller and private instructional spaces, etc. There is also an assumption that the Mass School Building Authority would kick in 33% of the cost. Scenario 1: Completion by FY27, estimated cost after reimbursement $245M Scenario 2: Completion in FY33, estimated cost after reimbursement $276M (but more reimbursement by MSBA) It is not that we are now choosing between a 16 and a 22 year timeline, rather these are two scenarios (out of many that may gel) used to illustrate different ways we might respond to facilities condition, educational requirements, and enrollment over time. Questions asked by School Committee members: - Geoff Epstein: which scenario would match your population projections best? Sandy Guryan said she wasn’t sure but would get back to him. - Margie Ross Decter: Is the plan to have one large preschool all under one roof, or for some elementary schools to house preschools. Sandy Guryan: “I’m not sure. I’m assuming in the short term which could be 3-4 yrs that there will be a different location for the preschool.” - Matt Hills: To what extent does our buffer zone policy impact these scenarios? Right now the buffer zone policy only takes kindergarten populations into account, should it be reviewed to take these issues into account. - Diana Fisher Gomburg: I know you said you assumed class size stays the same… how would scenarios look if you lowered class sizes. Sandy Guryan: “We added two classrooms per school that we labeled under “enrollment” but could be used for class size.” - Geoff Epstein: What about opening a 16th elementary school… we should consider cost per student of these additional small projects and compare to doing a 16th school. Sandy Guryan: “You could look at the chart and see Carr could be used as 16th school. But please note that opening a 16th elementary school does not fix the condition of any of the buildings, it just addresses the capacity side of things.” - Steve Siegel: I’m concerned with the certainty of enrollments. Private school enrollments look like a particular vulnerability. A 1% reduction in kids in private schools = 120 more kids in our system. Could be something we survey them about. Sandy Guryan: Some of them attend parochial schools or there is a family history of attending private school that appears to stay steady. - Geoff Epstein: Are we looking at the opportunity to bring more kids into the system [who are on IEPs but being educated outside Newton]? Superintendent David Fleishman: We don’t lose kids to out of district in elementary school, the issue in elementary school is having appropriate spaces to teach them in, which we don’t always have. A report on WBUR this morning notes that statewide, low income students are nearly twice as likely to be placed in special education programs as other students. The report authors speculate that many of these children may actually need extra educational help - with reading, with math - but instead are being designated as having a disability that in fact they don't have. I found it very interesting since this matches one of the conclusions of the consultants' evaluation of Newton's SPED program (pp. 44-49) - that we seem to be placing children on an IEP who do not really have a disability as a way to get them extra education support. Boston Celtics player Ray Allen's love of reading was profiled in this recent Boston Globe article: "He cannot remember what was in the contest jar - balls or jellybeans or other objects - but Celtics guard Ray Allen clearly recalls the prize he received as a first-grader at his Oklahoma elementary school. “I won three books,’’ Allen said with a smile. “I remember I felt so proud that I won those three books, those books were mine.’’ Allen traces his love of reading to that moment, and it continues today, as he uses the pleasures of a good book to ease the boredom of long road trips or soothe a particularly bad loss. To the world, Allen’s identity is as an NBA superstar with a smooth 3-point shot. But in the locker room, on the road, or waiting for a game to start, he is the guy with his nose in a book." Monday's meeting covered a lot of ground. Budget - Budget was passed unanimously (I covered the budget details in this blog post) - Administrators have found $60K+ in savings from unemployment, they are using that to restore some art time in upper elementary grades. (Last year art was cut from 60 to 45 min a week... it is unclear if the whole 15 min will be restored or less.) Full Day K, K Benchmarks Full Day K is definitely not in the works for fall of 2012, which is a disappointment to the 74% of parents who expressed support for it in a survey last year. Superintendent David Fleishman acknowledged that SC members have been asking about benchmarks in kindergarten and what they actually mean, since most K's are "reaching benchmark" yet our 3rd grade MCAS scores are all over the map. Are some kids backtracking in 1st and 2nd grade? Or are the K benchmarks set too low? (Personal anecdote - Last year I was told my kindergartner was "at benchmark", but at the end of the year he couldn't read. So I sent him to a tutor and she taught him to read. Ever since then I have been wondering what K "benchmarks" really represent) Newton Schools Foundation - NSF presented this MOU about naming rights. They project nearly $7M in donations from naming rights. (That's a big number, I hope they're right!) - They are reaching out to private individuals for substantial donations. - Ward 1 SC member Geoff Epstein asked to see a copy of the donor solicitation materials. Facilities Deputy Superintendent Sandy Guryan presented this memo about facilities planning including the rebuilding of the Angier School, the use of the former Carr School for swing space, and various school-related maintenance and repairs for FY13. - Carr currently has 18 classrooms, and could possibly be reconfigured to have 19. - Sept 2014 is the planned date to move Angier kids to Carr. - The exact cost to bring Carr up to snuff is not known, though it's "hopefully well under ten million dollars.” Ward 3 SC member Angela Pitter-Wright asked about moving the Lincoln-Eliot preschool (which takes up 4 classrooms) to Carr. Sandy Guryan said there should be changes made to combine the Ed Center preschool with the Lincoln Eliot preschool, but "that’s a longer term issue." SC voted 8-1 "to support the use of Carr School as swing space for anticipated school renovations and construction." Geoff Epstein was the sole vote against. He expressed some concern about how renovating Carr fits into the overall space crunch issue, and whether the planners are taking into account all of the relevant and interconnected factors that will come into play over the next 20 years. He said: - Carr will cost up to $10M to renovate, there are cheaper options such as leasing Aquinas which has been used as swing space before - If I vote for Carr, it looks like there won't be enough $ left to purchase Aquinas yet Carr really only deals with swing space needs, not additional space needs - in other words it does not solve all the problems. - Carr may remain empty in between school rebuilding projects as there are projected to be substantial time lapses between the Angier project and the next one on the list (Cabot). - If the city does not buy or lease Aquinas, that leaves it vulnerable to be purchased by developers for housing, which would further burden the overcrowded schools in the north of the city. - What will happen to current inhabitants of the building, which is now the Newton Cultural Center. - He did not like being asked to vote on Carr when the SC has still not seen the comprehensive plan for addressing school overcrowding and condition issues. His SC colleagues said he was going beyond the purview of what they were being asked to consider, which is whether Carr would be an appropriate building to use as swing space, and considering it used to be an elementary school, they felt it was. SC Chair Claire Sokoloff said "It’s too hypothetical to be thinking about buying a school to prevent it from being turned into condos." I found Geoff Epstein's concerns to be worth at least a discussion, especially if there are options for swing space that are cheaper and/or offer more flexibility. (The actual cost of leasing Aquinas was not discussed.) Sandy Guryan said the discussion about the timing of projects would take place at the next meeting (April 9). Why have that discussion after the vote for Carr? It did not feel that a full vetting of all options had taken place - at least not in public, that may be happening in private, I don't know. Technology Angela Pitter-Wright asked if the city has considered bonding for technology. Mayor Warren responded that they already do some and could do more, there is an IT Steering committee that could look at that. Angela also commented that the new teacher evaluation process (discussed in this blog post) seems like an unfunded mandate and that she thinks technology will be necessary in order to be able to manage it in a time efficient way. Assistant superintendent Joe Russo agreed and responded that he had recently attended a presentation by the Reading Public School system which is using a simple technology they are considering. He said "We are at the beginning phases of this, and working with Newton Teachers Association to put together a document. Once we have a document we can look at the options." He said that [Deputy Superintendent] "Ann Koufman-Frederick always pushes us to look at doing things in a digital way." Next meeting April 9, 7pm, 100 Walnut Street. From this week's Newton Tab: "In 2000, less than a third of kindergartners attended full-day programs, according to the state Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. This year, a vast majority, or 83 percent of Bay State kindergarten students, are enrolled in full-day classrooms, but Newton children aren’t among those." The article quotes Newton's superintendent as saying it would cost over a million dollars a year to implement, but as I pointed out in a previous post, that assumes we hire full time aides, which is not the only way of doing it - why not just hire part time aides to help during literacy and math instruction? Keep in mind that our Kindergarten teachers are already receiving a full time salary. The article also offers an interesting juxtaposition of quotes - our assistant superintendent of elementary education saying Newton doesn't need Full Day K, and the state commissioner of education saying something else: Many kindergartners can benefit from full-day programs, especially those who have attended little or no preschool and arrive in school with gaps in language and literacy, State Education Commissioner Mitchell Chester said recently. "A high-quality kindergarten experience that's rich in literature and language and numbers goes a long way toward mitigating those gaps," Chester said. "It's absolutely a critical experience." Our current hybrid program came about as a way to provide our K teachers with a full time salary. It was not designed out of concern for what is best for Newton children. It is time for Newton to get with the program. "It is known as “the cinnamon challenge.’’ You try to swallow a spoonful of cinnamon without drinking water - or vomiting - preferably as a video camera is rolling. It may sound like silly fun, but health professionals and a growing number of local school systems are warning parents that the practice can cause health problems including respiratory distress and choking." Read the whole article here According to this Education Week blog post by Sara Mead (who is also a former colleague of mine), southern states lead the say on Full Day Kindergarten by mandating it at far higher rates than other states, including Massachusetts. She writes: Kindergarten is a critical year for children's development and learning--and all the more so as states move to implement Common Core standards. And providing a full-day is important not only to ensure children are able to master the concepts and content that Common Core is expecting, but to ensure schools have time to support this learning in a developmentally appropriate way that leaves plenty of room for play and exploration, which are essential at age 5. |
